NYERI, Kenya — The Court of Appeal sitting in Nyeri has ruled that a father cannot be denied custody or access to his child on the basis of unpaid dowry, in a landmark judgment that reaffirms the primacy of child welfare over cultural obligations.
The case involved a custody dispute between a biological father and the maternal grandparents of a minor who had been raised by them since the death of the child’s mother during childbirth.
Following the bereavement, the father initially allowed the grandparents to care for the child as he dealt with hospital expenses and funeral arrangements. He also contributed intermittently towards the child’s upkeep.
However, tensions emerged after he later remarried and sought to have the child live with him. The grandparents refused, insisting that dowry for their late daughter be paid first.
Although the father eventually met the agreed dowry amount, the family still declined to release the child, prompting him to move to the Kerugoya court in 2017 seeking custody.
The grandparents argued that the father had not consistently provided financial support and had failed to fully comply with customary obligations, including dowry payment. They further alleged that his involvement in the child’s life had been minimal after birth.
However, after years of proceedings, the appellate court found that the man was the undisputed biological father and had demonstrated the capacity to care for the child, including stable income and provision of basic needs.
In its judgment delivered on March 27, 2026, the court held that parental responsibility cannot be overridden by cultural expectations where a child’s welfare is at stake.
“I find that the appellant, being the undisputed father of the minor, is the right person to have the legal and actual custody of the minor. It is not only morally wrong but unlawful to deny the father of the child who is alive and readily willing to take care of the child,” the court ruled.
The judges emphasised that the guiding principle in custody matters is the best interests of the child.
Also Read: Pastor Kanyari bows out, lets Betty Bayo’s children stay with the man who replaced him
“He is not only suitable but has also demonstrated that he has a stable job and income, which will ensure the minor enjoys a good life. There is absolutely no reason why she should be denied parental love and care,” the court added.
The court further noted that customary practices such as dowry cannot override constitutional protections relating to parental rights and child welfare.
Legal analysts say the ruling reinforces a growing body of jurisprudence in Kenya that prioritises the rights of the child over competing customary claims, particularly in post-bereavement custody disputes involving extended family members.
The judgment is expected to serve as a reference point in similar cases where cultural obligations are invoked in disputes over parental custody.
